Interview Questions to Identify Talent

Interview Questions to Identify Talent

August 26, 2025

·

5 minutes read

Hiring isn’t just about filling today’s vacancy—it’s about building your company’s future. High-potential employees (HiPos) are the individuals who consistently go beyond job requirements, adapt quickly, and show the drive to grow into leadership or specialized roles. Identifying these candidates during the interview stage can be tricky, but the right questions reveal much more than a resume ever could.

In this guide, we’ll cover:

  • What defines high-potential talent

  • Categories of interview questions to assess them

  • Sample questions you can use in your next interview

What Defines High-Potential Talent?

High-potential candidates aren’t necessarily the ones with the longest resumes or the flashiest credentials. Instead, they typically show:

  • Growth mindset – eagerness to learn and adapt.

  • Problem-solving ability – creativity and resilience under pressure.

  • Leadership potential – ability to influence and inspire others.

  • Cultural alignment – values and behaviors that match your organization.

Spotting these qualities during interviews requires asking behavioral and situational questions that go beyond technical skills.

✅ Category 1: Problem-Solving & Critical Thinking

High-potential employees thrive in ambiguity. Ask questions that reveal how they approach challenges.

Sample questions:

  • “Tell me about a time you faced a problem at work without a clear solution. What did you do?”

  • “Imagine our company launched a new product and customer adoption was slower than expected. What steps would you take to improve results?”

  • “When you don’t know the answer right away, how do you figure it out?”


👉 What to look for: structured thinking, creativity, and evidence of persistence.

✅ Category 2: Learning Agility

HiPos are fast learners who absorb feedback and apply it effectively.

Sample questions:

  • “What’s a skill you taught yourself recently? Why and how did you learn it?”

  • “Tell me about a time when you received tough feedback. How did you respond?”

  • “What’s something you failed at, and what did you take away from it?”

👉 What to look for: humility, adaptability, and a willingness to take risks for growth.

✅ Category 3: Leadership & Collaboration Potential

Even in non-management roles, HiPos often emerge as informal leaders.

Sample questions:

  • “Describe a situation where you influenced others without having direct authority.”

  • “Tell me about a project where you had to rally a team with different opinions.”

  • “If you were leading a team project and one member wasn’t pulling their weight, how would you handle it?”

👉 What to look for: communication skills, empathy, and conflict-resolution ability.

✅ Category 4: Motivation & Drive

High-potential employees are intrinsically motivated and aligned with organizational goals.

Sample questions:

  • “What excites you most about this role and our company?”

  • “What do you want your career to look like in three years?”

  • “When was the last time you went above and beyond your job description?”

👉 What to look for: passion, clarity of career goals, and alignment with company mission.

✅ Category 5: Cultural Fit & Values

Technical skills can be taught—values cannot. HiPos thrive when their personal values align with the company culture.

Sample questions:

  • “What type of work environment helps you perform at your best?”

  • “How do you handle disagreements with a manager or colleague?”

  • “If you could change one thing about a past employer’s culture, what would it be?”

👉 What to look for: alignment with your company’s mission, adaptability to your team’s dynamics, and respect for diverse perspectives.

Pro Tips for Interviewers

  • Use consistent evaluation rubrics so every candidate is assessed fairly.

  • Pair behavioral and situational questions for a balanced view.

  • Watch for curiosity and initiative—strong signs of high potential.

  • Don’t confuse charisma with capability—dig deeper with follow-ups.

Final Thoughts

High-potential employees are your future leaders and innovators. By asking targeted interview questions across problem-solving, learning agility, leadership, motivation, and cultural alignment, you can identify candidates who won’t just succeed in today’s role but will also help your organization grow tomorrow.

The key is to listen closely—not just to what they’ve achieved, but how they think, adapt, and aspire.

Holly Diamond

Holly “Oh” Diamond is the Founder & CEO of WorkOnward, a map-based platform connecting local talent with local jobs. She’s passionate about hourly work, inclusive hiring, and building thriving communities. Find Holly on Twitter and LinkedIn.

Holly “Oh” Diamond is the Founder & CEO of WorkOnward, a map-based platform connecting local talent with local jobs. She’s passionate about hourly work, inclusive hiring, and building thriving communities. Find Holly on Twitter and LinkedIn.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter

Out bi-weekly newsletter full of inspiration, podcasts, trends and news.

Out bi-weekly newsletter full of inspiration, podcasts, trends and news.

Read some more blogs

Read some more blogs

Read some more blogs

Read some more blogs

Get the app for a better mobile experience!

Follow us

Get the app for a better mobile experience!

Follow us